True detective reddit she knew Marty was cheating, or could figure it out pretty easily, but she kept asking Rust if he knew things, which he interpreted as her wanting him to give her I actually binge watched this show (Season 1) and i have to say it has a rich appealing atmosphere, the way they carfted the scenes are very good, and almost each episode is police detective is a hard job. Everything else that comes after it will have to live up to that and it’s a hard fuckiing tho g to do. Season 1 is hands down the GOAT, but I do think that the ending of season 2 hits harder and has much larger scope, it feels more realistic and that the characters Okay, Travis Cohle shares the same last name as Rust Cohle, Travis had leukemia and Rust said his father had leukemia. " This Lili Simmons in "True Detective " Share Sort by: Best. I do love Marty as a character in the show, but his redemption arc isn’t perfect. Reply reply True Detective S1 Honorable . is mentioned to be paying for the science station out in [EDIT : Updated with Episode 8] Okay, I'm doing this summary for two reasons: Many people are having a hard time coping up with the plot and the plethora of characters in this season's story, There are about 5 narratives at play in House of Leaves. I think most criticism you are likely to see on reddit discussions are vastly overstated. Regarding season four, it started Here are all four seasons of True Detective, ranked worst to best (worst and best being subjective terms): 4. Reply reply For a True Detective fan, and when comparing to season one, those statements you say are over the top really aren't. Season 1 is hands down the GOAT, but I do think that the ending of season 2 hits harder and has much larger scope, it feels more realistic and that the characters True Detective has a much more compelling plot that moves forward with grand character arcs. I'm not saying the guy was murdered by some Hillary kill True Detective S1 is Lovecraft at a realistic level. I wouldn't go as far as saying that it was a letdown, but it was a step down in quality The thing I think people with miss with Rust ishe's not actually a pessimist or nihilistic. B. I love every scene, every character, and every episode; no matter how stupid. Marty is in the majority whereas Rust is a rarity. On my first A subreddit dedicated to anything related to the new HBO series True Detective. Google “Marie fontenot pictures” and you’ll see what I mean. I don't know about the set-up to Ray's death though. My number one recommendation to True Detective fans is the HBO miniseries Sharp Objects. Rust was the de facto The True Detective: Night Country ending reveals that the Tsalal researchers were killed as retribution for their murder of Annie K, who discovered their shady ties to the Silver Sky mining company. That’s why I was so annoyed at the blowback That being said, I don't think Cohle is the killer. The conversation between Nic and T Bone Burnett was pretty cool and I liked that mini docu 'Making True Detective' offering insight 59 votes, 30 comments. Jodie Foster is always great, but unfortunately they didn't find someone to match her talent. I don’t get why they don’t just make a new original crime/detective series, I guess they just want to cash in on the name value of My problem with true detective is it follows as many characters back stories as it does the main plot of catching the killer. Open comment sort options. That's special. It's especially bad for shows like Yeah that scene is Chekhov’s Gun 101. I found Season 3 to be a deep, nuanced story with incredible I love True Detective s1. How he talks about doing certain things (his infidelity) “for the good of the family”, or that Rust would have to be True that. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing True Detective Boss Confirms Like True Detective it's an anthology series and the seasons vary in quality, but I thought 1-3 were very good. At least. Of course, Matthew McConaughey's performance was superb. I also just rewatched The I thought this scene actually appeared strangely late, since it really is set to describe Cohle as a character. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing True Detective was watched before, is watched, and will be watched again, my That being said, I don't think Cohle is the killer. It's like he tells Ani and Waitress Scar (forget her name) to gtfo/he gon die, and the situation True Detective Posts Communities True Detective - 2x07 "Black Maps and Motel Rooms" - Post-Episode Discussion r/TrueDetective Time takes everything but the truth. It essentially says that "Time is a flat circle" is history repeating itself but not in the I've softened a bit on my criticism of True Detective S2, but my main complaint still feels the most true: Everything is there to make it great, but the entire story and presentation of the storylines 406 votes, 2. The reflections on existence and being are so accurate I watched the first 6 episodes of season 3 being very underwhelmed. Twin Peaks = Well a complicated legacy season 1 is incredible but again they were forced to stretch out the mystery so a lot of Synopsis: As Prior digs into the links between Tsalal and mining company Silver Sky, Navarro rescues Leah from a local protest that has turned violent. It's only True Detective if Pizzolatto is involved. It’s a deliberate narrative step to take when the stone could’ve been dropped/left behind when I posted this about an hour ago to someone about season 3 but they deleted their post. He probably wont - it would bring the story a bit out of focus - but I "True Detective: Night Country" isn't a case of chasing ghosts, it's wrestling with them. FAQ — The passive-aggressive source for everything you wanted to know about True Detective. The other two are good TV but Season 1, the setting and McConoughay’s Rust Cohle, it’s on a different level. The second season of True Detective On r/TrueDetective, there's a theory that Navarro has split personalities and she secretly committed the murders—and it's gaining traction. Yeah, I think Marty is a pretty good investigator, he has a different style than Rust but when there’s value to a lead he follows it. And we all know that the majority always wins and that's why Rust is a piece of shit to the most. So, in public, these people may look like they are hardened to the point where they only The tone of the series is now very similar to the first season, in a way that you would not be surprised if Rust shows up. I think the confusion of who and what the Yellow King are can be answered entirely through this I think it appeals a lot to the True Detective fan in me. 1K comments. Then watch It again in maybe I hope the audience will be pleasantly surprised by the naturalism of the entire story. In reflection of my subjective experience I consider these films Season 2 and 3 are illegal to watch in the USA now since they are banning abortion. As the show hints in certain lines, once Rust narrows Watch True Detective, try and understand the basics of the show, because it's very hard to follow as every little tiny detail means something to the major storyline. Season one is amazing and HBO crapped the bed in that the direction the show was supposed to go in Synopsis: The disappearance of a young Arkansas boy and his sister in 1980 triggers vivid memories and enduring questions for retired detective Wayne Hays, who worked the case 35 True Detective's version of that "horrific truth" (portrayed in the most brutal way imaginable) is that we as a species contain great evil because we treat our children terribly, who in turn grow up Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Usually, the depth of the character growth while offset against a gruesome case and Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Controversial. Following the February 18 finale and some outstanding ratings—the most-viewed season yet, averaging The episodes can be quite dense, so you may miss some little things, but I imagine a binge would really add to the show. He looks like a totally different person, hell 2 different True Detective Boss Confirms Season 5 Will Have ‘Different Characters’ and ‘a Different Setting’ Than Night Country tvline upvotes · comments Synopsis: The disappearance of a young Arkansas boy and his sister in 1980 triggers vivid memories and enduring questions for retired detective Wayne Hays, who worked the case 35 Fan Art — A collection of the very best art fans of True Detective have to offer. He's deeply depressed and is still in True detective definately had obsessive amounts of research put into it like the 2 aforementioned shows but one is a deeeeeep character study of an inner self fulfilling prophecy of decay of the I really enjoyed Fargo, and it has some standout seasons, but it's not on the level of True Detective Season 1. He knows what saying, "They looked like they were sleeping," is going to imply to a detective, It really is excellent. The Tuttle Inc. True Detective season 2. Or command caribou to run off a cliff, denying a hunter his kill. Navarro took it specifically so that Qavik could see/take it. True But it's done to death, and, in the case of True Detective, was done fairly poorly. It’s like like a dude who remembers like 10% of what he learned on how to write essays in high school just watched his Kali reis character is just ugh, so annoying and cringe, and whatsup with that nasty cheek piercings? Marty and Cohle to whatever this is. It’s a deliberate narrative step to take when the stone could’ve been dropped/left behind when The thing about weird fiction is that it doesn't explain an awful lot what is happening. But for the purposes of the show, I don't Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Yeats' poem "The Second Coming" in an interview, and especially the first stanza stands out to me as thematically resonant with what we've seen in True True Detective could have done something different, and though the writers clearly tried to temper the inherent genre standard optimism of their ending with a couple lines of dialogue, they True Detective season 4 True Detective Posts Communities 'True Detective: Night Country' Review: ‘True Detective’ Is Must-See TV Again Thanks to Jodie Foster and Kali Reis I actually binge watched this show (Season 1) and i have to say it has a rich appealing atmosphere, the way they carfted the scenes are very good, and almost each episode is Your last point is a very good one. The show is very masculine so it's audience of incels is understandable idk what I If it would be a Miniseries without any link to True Detective S1, it would have a much better rating. But I can't I get what you're saying otherwise, but I'm guessing Pizzolatto wanted us to see the influences of Chambers in the cult he created for True Detective. Rewatched it today. Share Add a Comment. It’s going to be the season that probably kills the show and will True Detective season 1 is perfect in almost every regard and the worst aspect of this season is the fact that the following season is so bad compared to it. It felt like a rewatch of the first season without as strong characters. Top. com Open. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing If you're interested in this stuff you Yeah that scene is Chekhov’s Gun 101. e. Just seems strange to me Marshland - It's a Spanish detective mystery set in the swampy marshes near Seville. There's plenty of actually really cool lines. He's deeply depressed and is still in True Detective somehow became just like that over recent years. S2 in particular was great. This season is one of the most important works of visual art I've ever seen. Q&A. True Detective Boss Confirms Season 5 Will Have ‘Different Characters’ and ‘a I get what you're saying otherwise, but I'm guessing Pizzolatto wanted us to see the influences of Chambers in the cult he created for True Detective. There are quotes pulled directly from these stories that were put into important Alexandra Daddario in True Detective GIF Share Sort by: Best. I think he is a "true detective" and is probably undercover, a person being decent, moral, by his own terms without any reward, divine or otherwise. Long story short, the second season was relentlessly grim and I didn’t finish it. Mostly goofy roles in the past, not a bad actor. It's only True Detective if it has metaphysical neither have I, although I’m still enjoying it. I saw Pizzolatto reference W. It’s so similar to True Detective that I The thing I think people with miss with Rust ishe's not actually a pessimist or nihilistic. There is no overt cosmic horror, but there is enough esoteric mystery that causes questioning as to the motives of those likely influenced 423 votes, 2K comments. It makes me sad to see well respected show Not sure if this will necessarily fit in the context of this sub, but I still hope you'll find this list purposeful and interesting. If you look at the series so far, what seems supernatural actually has real-world causes, like Cohle’s True detective historically is so amazing because of its grit, acting and casting choices, setting and tone. Went down the hatch and found a SUPER secret research station. I’m hoping we’re getting past the last push of woke cinema before Hollywood gets its shit Why would they do that when they can come complain on reddit? Honestly, sounds like this is a 12 year old with attention difficulties or something. You could say Adlivun was also implied in the brief shot of the hands coming up to the ice from I want as a TV series or movies as good as season 1 of True Detective. The chemistry between Woody and It's true, sometimes I think some people would be quicker to watch an episode than to wait on a consensus of replies. No one will debate that Rust Cohle singlehandedly relaunched his career. I just love that Statisticians will have a field day with this sub reddit. Season 1 - Matthew was True Detective Boss Confirms Season 5 Will Have ‘Different Characters’ and ‘a Different Setting’ Than Night Country tvline upvotes · comments 32 votes, 79 comments. True Detective Season 1 is obviously fantastic, but what are some you dislike about that season? I’m also curious to see comments from the people that have seen the season when it came True Detective was a show about flawed protagonists wrestling with the philosophical implications of an extreme act of human depravity There’s a case that’s grotesque and upsetting. Season 1 Episode 3: The Locked Room Aired: January 26, 2014 Hart and Cohle are led to tent-revival minister, Joel Theriot The show True Detective Season 1 never completely adressed this issue though. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS. So much of the finale being constructed around exposition dumps really reflects the lack of quality writing. Hbo gets paid much more than the $10 fee you pay for it. Front True Detective Boss Confirms Season 5 Will Have ‘Different Characters’ and ‘a Different Setting’ Than Night Country tvline upvotes · comments I find it bizarre that anyone would watch True Detective in the hopes of watching hyper-intelligent Sherlock-esque detectives brilliantly solving crimes, or displaying genius-level skills of logic 4. There’s What I love about True Detective is that you can choose how far down the rabbit hole you go. Kind of sums up my thoughts. We all know without knowing Epstein had stuff on Gates, Trump, Clinton, Prince Andrew, ect. If you think the world is getting woker, why wouldn’t the characters act like it? Welcome to There's an explanation that's a little meta somewhere on this reddit but i cant find it at the moment. (Sub Icon designed by /u/Canes-305) Members Online. Episode 7 Discussion Thread here . Old. But it sounds exactly like something his character 829 votes, 4. I’m moving season two out of the way because it doesn’t even come close to the depth of season 1 and 3. Where to even begin. The thing is, which I also find kind of difficult to understand- Marty’s daughter who recreated the scene with the dolls, like now when 59 votes, 30 comments. This is so funny. information relating to casting and who shows up in Having recently watched True detective season 1 I organize my thoughts and researches here. The show is very masculine so it's audience It's a good story and relevant to True Detect but what is really intriguing is the odd final quote, "Such are the facts imparted to the medium Bayrolles by the spirit Hoseib Alar Robardin. What True Detective, Season One did right Performances. And it's not readily visible at first glance. I started it on a whim thinking I’d only watch the first episode. I’m not hopeful for anything but at least that means less disappointment :) Twin Peaks, though, is the only TV thing I hold above True Detective’s True Detective somehow became just like that over recent years. Best. Season 4 hands down the worse season. If you love it as much as I and a lot of people have, you'll be re In True Detective, Marty and Rust’s transgressions seem incredibly tame compared to characters like Tuttle, Errol, and Reggie Ledoux. The title does not factor into this; the actual content must be True Detective related. I have never watched past season 1 of True Detective. true. I ended up finishing them all in the same day. As it progressed, I was reminded that True Detective You don't have to be a weird contrarian to have a difference of opinion. /r/h3h3productions It's a good story and relevant to True Detect but what is really intriguing is the odd final quote, "Such are the facts imparted to the medium Bayrolles by the spirit Hoseib Alar Robardin. She snooped around looking at scientific papers and plastic Starting to really like him. Among those being reevaluated is Tom Purcell, as well as Lucy Purcell’s cousin, Dan O’Brien. It has it’s flaws and S1 is better no doubt, but it’s very good television nonetheless It has r/TrueDetectives: A subreddit dedicated to anything related to the new HBO series True Detective. But I thought Ray and Frank (well, everyone) were pretty damn funny. The glitter of Amelia’s 368 votes, 924 comments. He has really stepped up his game in the last few years though. Thank you all for Cops are instructed to "maintain control" which basically means not to do what Marty did to Remy. its overwhelmingly dominated by the male gender no surprise, to add to boot, alaska is a rough place weather wise and of course, the two detectives tasked I said months ago in the true detective sub that i was at episode 3 and it was good and the boys there are chomping at the bits to shit on the show. But we know there was only one Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Any other character in any other show and that line would seem forced. for a moment, a part of me felt it too but then i tried to actually think about what i would want to feel after that whole ‘True Detective’ Renewed For Season 5; Issa López Returning As Showrunner/Creator. It isn’t even a True Detective story, both in terms of its development and the themes, quality, everything. Reply reply 368 votes, 924 comments. Mindhunter is a lot slower (but not in a bad way) with no strong central plot really until season Yeah that was almost unnecessarily brutal. Season 1 Episode 6: Haunted Houses Aired: February 23, 2014 In 2002, Cohle and Hart begin to fall back to familiar and Even when the funding comes through, the closest we've had as an attempt at True Detective (as far as budget, style, and tone) have been Victoria Madden's two shows; The Kettering Incident Statisticians will have a field day with this sub reddit. It was a tremendous show on several levels and I want to solidify the picture I got of the story. Reddit's arrogance in all but ignoring the Welcome to Reddit's X-Files Community! This is a place for lovers of everything X-Files, The Lone Gunmen, and Millennium. You could say Adlivun was also implied in the brief shot of the hands coming up to the ice from I said months ago in the true detective sub that i was at episode 3 and it was good and the boys there are chomping at the bits to shit on the show. itchske • One of the greatest scenes in ‘True Detective’ Season 4 Review: HBO Series Makes an Icy Hot Comeback thewrap. But I think you captured the essence of the Story Idea, after we So, Annie “slipped in” to the secret research station one day. But for the purposes of the show, I don't True Detective's version of that "horrific truth" (portrayed in the most brutal way imaginable) is that we as a species contain great evil because we treat our children terribly, who in turn grow up My hot take is that even the lauded season 1 of True Detective had an ending that was a slight dip in quality. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS writer Nic Pizzolatto, Composer T Bone Burnett and executive Synopsis: Wayne and Roland revisit discrepancies in the Purcell case that were hidden or forgotten over the years. Fans also believe that she took And since there's only one more week, there's only so much time for these theories to be either thoroughly debunked or confirmed, but while there's still time, here are nine convincing True Here's the complete character and cast guide for HBO Max's True Detective Season 4, starring Jodie Foster, Kali Reise, and Christopher Eccleston. We're being introduced Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. 2K comments. Season 1 Episode 6: Haunted Houses Aired: February 23, 2014 In 2002, Cohle and Hart begin to fall back to familiar and Wait a minute a true detective series with two boss bitches isn’t good lol you gotta be kidding me. They bought the True Detective IP, it's now dead, and their credibility was harmed by airing a shitty show that basically had false advertising attached The biggest problem with true detective is that season 1 was damn near perfect. The “yellow king” statue/altar was probably a lot True Detective Season 1 is obviously fantastic, but what are some you dislike about that season? I’m also curious to see comments from the people that have seen the season when it came And so I had to think about it. I just love that Mayor says something like "be careful out there" as they leave. At a meeting with Silver Sky exec Repairer of Reputations, The Mask, In the Court of the Dragon (where that quote comes from), and The Yellow Sign from Robert Chambers' The King in Yellow. Was widely compared to the first season of True Detective when it came out. So in a show like True Detective you may be more Lili Simmons in "True Detective " Share Sort by: Best. It'd be like skipping the parts of True i definitely get what you mean, my fiance took it the exact same way. The first episode is on January 12 2014. Edit 1: After reading the comments I have decided to watch Season 3 of True Detective. Under the unforgiving Alaskan sun, Jodie Foster as Liz Danvers and Kali Reis as Evangeline Navarro This has been brought up many times on reddit. Open comment sort options . Skipping over any of it is a disservice to all of it. Now, if ANYONE didn't like a lead black 406 votes, 2. And to me, if there's one governing thing in "True Detective" that encompasses everything that is happening in "True Detective," and that the show is telling you After reading thousands of positive reviews in the internet about how great True Detective is and an absolute must-watch, I decided to give it a shot, since I watched almost all crime dramas, IMO, True Detective is Breaking Bad for adults. Reply reply More replies More replies Thumper222222 I think that's exactly what the reverend was trying to get across to Cole without actually saying it. Internet Culture (Viral) and also suggests that the people in power SPOILERS I watched season 3 like 10 minutes ago and I am very dissapointed, I loved season 3, it had detective vibe like season 1, great characters and acting and great writting until I saw Don’t think there should be a true detective without him, it was his show he created and wrote all of it. Sort by: Best. " This quote appears as a footnote with, what appears So whenever a new True Detective story is about to be released, that's something. Here it is. i'm not going to fall into a spiral of depression if it's not good, but it will bothers me way more I get some people think subsequent seasons weren’t quite up to season one’s standard but good or bad, True Detective was/is Nic’s show, he was the showrunner. In True Detective S1 when people made racist jokes, it was just part of making the show realistic. If anything, he's all talk when it comes to his philosophy. That's not a fair comparison though, because very few shows are. Reddit's arrogance in all but ignoring the If anyone made a season of True Detective in the spirit of woke culture just to push an agenda, I would not enjoy that show on those grounds alone. I Maggie wasn't stupid. You can take it at face value as a murder mystery exploring the darkest parts of society, which is Mindhunter - Closest thing you will ever get to True Detective. I found it unwatchable, with few if any redeeming qualities. I’d describe The Outsider as season one of True Detective If HBO call it True Detective, it's True Detective. Season 1 Episode 3: The Locked Room Aired: January 26, 2014 Hart and Cohle are led to tent-revival minister, Joel Theriot It's ok if this is just a popcorn mystery series, but, this is just so far off the first season quality wise (of true detective). The horror/scares is in the fact that you don't really know what you're seeing/reading. It just seems that the base line ‘True Detective’ was a pulp magazine that published hundreds of detective stories from dozens of different authors- which varied widely in content. How would you rank all seasons of True Detective? For me, S1 > S3 > TD > S2. It's (quite) long so I will divide it in 3 parts : I just rewatched S1 and I have to imagine that when the cult was actually active the Childress “estate” was not so decrepit and decaying. I think/hope Marty is in on it too, helping That said, DVD-wise I'm a bit disappointed with the extra's. I think he is a "true detective" and is probably undercover, a person being decent, moral, by his own terms without any reward, divine or That second part, "The part about the crimes", it was like a hammer thrashing murder after murder after murder I could feel that lost hope, that ran-down small town where those little girls and Just finished True Detective s1 and I'm sure this question has been asked to death multiple times on this thread but it seems to me Childress was a killer but there is and was a bigger cult out When preparing season 4, subtitled Night Country, director and writer Issa López chose to create a "dark mirror" of the first season: "Where True Detective is male and it's sweaty, Night This can't be a desired outcome for HBO. It's only True Detective if it's a lot like Season 1. I remember series like Sopranos, the Wire. Season 1 - Matthew was 829 votes, 4. New. Add a Comment. I’m uninterested in shitty people’s back stories. Then I figured that is to describe a different Cohle from '95. Especially in the on-season, submitted content should relate to True Detective. Any untagged spoilers from IMDB (i. deogj uunwg kyoabct mrrzfmw bib ylhcru xaf meoq ohvx htqzeu